Soul Ponderings
So I took a little time off of writing, and it was nice. I actually expected to come back with lots of things to talk about, but it was less crazy than I expected. I had a little vacation to visit some family, and between the very liberal and very conservative members present, I expected more of a clash. Way to go everyone for keeping it friendly.
Still, there were a couple of interesting topics brought up that got me thinking. They have to do with the idea of a soul, and how to reconcile that with various situations. Personally, I have trouble with the word “soul” because it’s so inimately tied to religious connotations. On top of that, people generally describe a soul as “non-physical”, which leads me to ask what that actually means, usually to unsatisfying answers. Anyway, the topics that really made this conversation interesting to me were these: What would be the implications of being able to transfer consciousness between people/bodies? What are the implications of a soul in evolutionary terms?
First scenario – If you believe in a soul, do you think that it might be possible (in theory) to move consciousness from one body to another. To put it another way, if we had the ability to exactly reproduce the electrical workings of your brain in another body (or even some mechanical replica), would that still be you? Is there something beyond this that makes you, you? It’s an interesting possibility. For people who think that there is a non-physical soul that is really “you”, how would this get transferred, or would it? If it did not, what happened to it? If it did, are there some rules involved in how much of your brain activity needs to be transferred before the soul makes the jump too? What about if we just copied your consciousness over, and now there are two places your soul needs to be associated with? For those that think that you couldn’t transfer a soul this way, I want to know why. What is it about this body that ties it to my soul? If I lose some part of my physical body, I assume that I retain my soul. Then what’s the tie to my physical body? And if we can reproduce my consciousness, did we implicitly reproduce my soul somehow? If we copy my consciousness into a mechanical replica, do you have the same moral obligations to it that you do to me? What a metaphysical can of worms this is.
Second scenario – Does evolution lead to rejecting the idea of a soul? Most soul-advocates would agree that animals do not have one (except sometimes the family dog, which we’d like to see again in the afterlife). Many of them also want to be science-savvy and open-minded about evolution, but I have to ask, are the two compatible? To accept evolution is to accept that we share a common ancestor with creatures that have no soul. So then, somewhere along the way some creature must have had no soul, but given birth to one that did have a soul. Is this what we’re really saying? Where did that soul come from? At which point in the evolutionary line did we become just-human-enough to deserve a soul? Did that child have the same moral responsibility to its mother that we grant to fully human parents and children, or was its mother just an animal?
I don’t have good answers for most of this stuff, but it sure is mind-bending to think about and discuss. If you have good answers for what I see as logical problems with a soul here, let me know. I’m very interested.
![[del.icio.us]](http://images.del.icio.us/static/img/delicious.small.gif){kind=small}
OpenOffice Download…
[...]listed below are a handful of web links to online sites I always connect to as we feel they are worthwhile browsing[...]…
ICICI Money to India…
[...]following are a few listings to webpages which we connect to as we feel they’re well worth checking out[...]…
Trackback…
[...]we find pleasure in linking to other places on the interwebz, even though those places don’t happen to be similar to us, by pointing them out. Here are a couple URLs worth browsing[...]…
M1 Student…
[...]I think it has a certain level of effort to have such level in header design. Must be a[...]…
M1 Re-Contract…
[...]I have addded to a few of the awesome blog we have came across this fortnight. Our IT team[...]…
OpenOffice Download…
[...]in the following are a couple of web page links to websites online we connect to seeing that we believe they will be truly worth checking out[...]…
Travel Deals…
[...]several online websites which are posted under, from our own standpoint are certainly worth browsing[...]…
Cheapest Kasper Suits…
[...]right here are a couple of web page links to internet sites I always connect to because we believe they’re definitely worth checking out[...]…
Trackback…
[...]Sites of interest we like to link to[...]…
Get Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]what follows are several web page links to web-sites that we link to because we think they really are worthwhile visiting[...]…
OpenOffice Download…
[...]the following are some urls to sites we link to seeing that we believe they are worth browsing[...]…
ICICI Money to India…
[...]listed below are a handful of listings to online websites we connect to because we believe they will be worth browsing[...]…
Discount Kasper Suits…
[...]listed here are a few web page links to sites that we connect to seeing that we think they are worthy of checking out[...]…
downloading music for free…
[...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[...]…
The Best Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]in the following are a handful of urls to web pages I always link to seeing as we believe they are truly worth browsing[...]…
Apply for Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]here are a handful of listings to websites online I always connect to for the fact we feel they really are definitely worth browsing[...]…
Lu Paredes…
[...]homeowners insurance Georgia is similar to insurance as we cover for our life gives us money safeguarding ourselves[...]…
Cheapest Kasper Suits…
[...]listed here are some references to websites that we link to since we think they’re worthy of checking out[...]…
Online Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]what follows are a few references to web pages I always link to for the fact we believe they will be worthy of checking out[...]…
Get Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]these are a handful of links to web sites which we connect to since we feel they’re worthwhile browsing[...]…
Travel Offers…
[...]all of these websites might not be entirely relevant to our web site however we certainly feel you should go to all of them[...]…
Aldo Lopez…
[...]Georgia is one of the excellent cities with the hopeful and the helpful to the people with the great achievement [...]…
Online Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]listed here are some web page links to internet sites we link to seeing that we believe there’re worthwhile checking out[...]…
OpenOffice Download…
[...]below are a few web page links to web sites we connect to seeing that we feel they really are definitely worth browsing[...]…
Video to MP3…
[...]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[...]…
Get Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]these are several urls to online sites I always connect to seeing as we think they really are worthwhile checking out[...]…
tiguan 2010…
[...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]…
Cheapest Kasper Suits…
[...]right here are some urls to online websites we link to seeing as we think these are seriously worth browsing[...]…
Antonia Cook…
[...]Because here one can order a quote from multiple conservatories for free without any obligation[...]…
Title…
CMA salaries are as high as other medical careers…..
The Best Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]right here are some listings to web pages that we link to for the fact we think they are seriously worth visiting[...]…
Yours Truly…
[...]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[...]…
Discount Kasper Suits…
[...]here are a couple of hyper-links to places we link to since we think they’re worth browsing[...]…
Your style is so unique compared to many other people. Thank you for publishing when you have the opportunity,Guess I will just make this bookmarked.2…
Those are yours alright! . We at least need to get these people stealing images to start blogging! They probably just did a image search and grabbed them. They look good though!…
ICICI Money to India…
[...]these are several web page links to places we link to seeing as we believe they really are seriously worth browsing[...]…
casino…
casino…
The Best Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]below are a few web links to websites which we link to seeing as we feel they really are really worth checking out[...]…
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter[...]…
[...] Read the rest of this excellent post here…. [...]…
Escorts in London…
[...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]…
OpenOffice Download…
[...]following are a couple of links to web pages we connect to since we believe there’re definitely worth checking out[...]…
Money For College Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]listed here are a few listings to websites that we link to since we believe they are really worth browsing[...]…
Get Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]the following are a couple of hyper-links to internet websites which I connect to since we feel they’re seriously worth checking out[...]…
Apply for Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]following are a few references to internet pages which we connect to seeing as we feel these are worthy of checking out[...]…
[...] our site list of interesting sites on the web[...]…
[...] Top news, thought we could combine a few not related data, yet still worth looking!!![...]…
Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]right here are several links to web pages I always connect to for the fact we feel they are well worth visiting[...]…
Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]here are several listings to online sites we link to since we think they are well worth checking out[...]…
know…
[...]Alcohol, smoking and drugs are the major bad habits to replenish your body with abnormal effects[...]…
Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]here are a few links to web pages which I connect to as we believe these are definitely worth browsing[...]…
The Best Scholarships for Minorities…
[...]below are a handful of references to internet sites which I link to seeing as we think they will be worthwhile browsing[...]…
Onion…
[...]If you are on funds, you have to determine which items would profit you essentially the most and purchase them initially[...]…